Membrane dryer vs refrigerated dryer: which fits your application?

Table of contents

Why dry your compressed air?
Refrigerated dryers
Membrane dryers: simple, flexible, and maintenance-free
Comparing the two technologies
Making the right choice
FAQs

Selecting the right dryer for your compressed air system is key to protecting your equipment, maintaining efficiency, and ensuring reliable operation. Among the common dryer technologies available today, membrane dryers and refrigerated dryers each offer distinct advantages, but they’re best suited for different applications and operating conditions. In this article, we’ll explore how each technology works, their strengths, limitations, and how to decide which is the right choice for your needs.

Why dry your compressed air?

When air is compressed, moisture in the air becomes more concentrated. If this moisture isn’t removed before reaching downstream equipment, it can cause corrosion, damage pneumatic tools, contaminate products, and increase maintenance costs. A compressed air dryer removes this moisture, helping protect your system and improving overall performance.

Refrigerated dryers

How they work

Refrigerated dryers cool the compressed air to near-freezing temperatures so that water vapor condenses into liquid water, which can then be removed. The dry air is usually reheated before it exits the dryer to prevent condensation later in the system. This process leverages familiar refrigeration technology which is similar in principle to air conditioning.

Key benefits

• Reliable for general industrial use: Refrigerated dryers provide a stable pressure dew point (typically around 3–7 °C or 37–45 °F), making them suitable for a wide range of manufacturing and process environments.
• Low maintenance: These systems are designed for easy installation and long service intervals with minimal operator maintenance.
• Energy efficient: Many models offer advanced features like variable speed drives (VSD) that adapt energy use to actual air demand, reducing operational costs.
• Broad capacity range: Refrigerated dryers are available in many sizes and configurations, well-suited for general plant air systems.

Typical applications

Refrigerated dryers are ideal for facilities where moisture removal is needed in general industrial environments, such as manufacturing floors, automotive shops, packaging operations, or facilities supplying pneumatic tools, and where the dew point provided by refrigeration meets quality requirements.

Membrane dryers: simple, flexible, and maintenance-free

How they work

Membrane dryers use bundles of tiny hollow fibers with a specialized coating that selectively allows water vapor to permeate through the membrane material. As compressed air flows through the membrane, water vapor diffuses out, while dry air continues through the system. This process doesn’t require electricity or moving parts and uses a very small amount of purge air to carry away the separated moisture.

Key benefits

• No electricity or moving parts: Membrane dryers operate without electrical power or mechanical components, making them inherently simple, quiet, and low risk in sensitive environments.
• Low maintenance: With no motors or consumables to service, maintenance requirements are extremely low.
• Compact and flexible: Their size and simplicity make membrane dryers ideal for point-of-use applications or places where electrical power is unavailable or restricted. Can be installed horizontally or vertically depending on the application’s space constraints.
• High performance in small footprints: Available in models with different pressure dew point ratings, membrane dryers can deliver reliable drying for many small and critical applications.

Typical applications

Membrane dryers are particularly suited for point-of-use drying, compact installations, laboratories, explosion-proof environments, and remote locations where electrical power may not be available or where a compact, low-maintenance dryer is preferred.

Comparing the two technologies

Choose a refrigerated dryer if your application requires a reliable, stable dew point across a wide range of flow conditions and you’re drying compressed air for an entire system. These are typically the most common dryers used in plant environments due to their balance of performance, capacity, and cost.

Choose a membrane dryer if you have smaller flow requirements, need drying at specific points of use, lack electrical power at the location, or want an extremely low-maintenance option that fits into a compact space.

Making the right choice

Your choice between a membrane and a refrigerated dryer should be guided by your air quality requirements, system size, installation environment, and maintenance preferences. Refrigerated dryers excel in broader industrial settings where whole-system moisture control is critical, while membrane dryers offer simplicity, compactness, and versatility for targeted applications.

If you’re unsure which technology aligns best with your needs, consulting an air treatment expert can help clarify the trade-offs and ensure you get the right dryer for your compressed air system.

Refrigerated dryers are the go-to solution for general industrial air-drying needs, offering stable performance and energy efficiency. Membrane dryers stand out when you need simplicity, flexible installation, and minimal ongoing maintenance, especially at the point of use. Understanding your application will ensure you choose the right technology and protect your system effectively.

Want more information. Reach out to our experts today. 

FAQs